Being 'Unpopular' Could Have Saved You Money This Quarter -- and Next

Millions of mutual fund investors are staring at their account balances and wondering how they went so wrong.

Other Junk

Redemptions at Janus Soar

Building the Low-Maintenance Portfolio

Questioning the Buy-and-Hold Strategy

(Re)Building a Diversified Portfolio

The Junkie's Perfect Portfolio

Fact is, if you built a seemingly sensible portfolio of funds in the past five or 10 years, it was quite easy to end up with a tech-stuffed gaggle that's falling through the floor. When tech dusted the rest of the market in 1998 and 1999, pro and amateur investors alike chased the sizzling sector. A record gush of money flowed into tech funds and "diversified" growth-fund managers quietly put 40% and 50% of their money in tech stocks, too. Today we detailed the steep losses these funds -- and their shareholders -- are still absorbing.

Ariba Wins the Award That No Company Wanted

The Best- and the Worst-Performing Stocks of First Quarter 2001

Valuations Will Determine Where Stocks Go Now

Bubble's Gone, but Bubble Thinking Still Distorts This Market

Fund Investors: Do Not Feed the Bears

Being 'Unpopular' Could Have Saved You Money This Quarter -- and Next

No Quarter: The Fund World Offers Few Ports in 2001's First Quarter

The upshot: Even a portfolio that seemed only moderately aggressive was actually positioned to fall -- and fall hard -- in this tech-led downturn. Let's look at one and then check out some simple alternatives you can use to cut your risk way down, without sacrificing competitive returns. I'm not telling you to buy these funds, I'm just trying to show you how easy it can be to get marketlike returns without a slew of risk.

Over the past few years, it seemed like everybody was buying S&P 500 index funds, big-cap growth funds, focused growth funds that held only 20 or so stocks and tech funds. If we build a portfolio of the biggest, most popular funds in each style, it would include the Vanguard 500 fund, the Fidelity Magellan fund, the Janus Twenty fund and the T. Rowe Price Science & Technology fund. Let's call it the Popular Portfolio. Yes, Magellan and Twenty are currently closed to new investors, but given their asset size, there is no shortage of folks with these funds, and funds like them, in their portfolios.

The Popular Portfolio
25%	(VFINX)Vanguard 500 Index
25%	(FMAGX)Fidelity Magellan
25%	(JAVLX)Janus Twenty
25%	(PRSCX)T. Rowe Price Science & Technology

While this probably seemed like a moderately aggressive portfolio, it was actually pretty risky. If we look at the sector weightings of an equally weighted portfolio of these four funds we find that it would have more than half its money in the tech sector, according to Morningstar. Keep in mind, the telecommunications sector is a big part of the portfolio's "services" bet, so about 60 cents of every dollar in this portfolio is pegged to mercurial and currently sagging tech/telecom stocks.

They're a Techy Bunch These four funds won their fans by riding the tech wave -- till it crashed
Sector	Weighting in Portfolio	Weighting in S&P 500
Technology	50.9%	19%
Services	12.6	11.9
Financials	10	17.5
Cyclicals	7.5	12
Health Care	7	13.8
Retail	3.9	6.5
Energy	3.7	7.6
Consumer Staples	2.3	6.8
Consumer Durables	1.3	1.9
Utilities	1	2.9
Source: Morninigstar. Weightings as of most recent portfolio reports.

This Popular Portfolio's tech bet was probably apparent when it sailed high in 1998 and 1999, but it's even more noticeable now. It's down almost 32% over the past 12 months through Feb. 28, according to Morningstar. That's about four times the loss of a portfolio invested just in the Vanguard 500 Index fund, where tech is about 19% of the portfolio.

Even more stark is a look at the Popular Portfolio's volatility. Yes, over the past 10 years its best 12-month return was 67.8%, but its worst 12-month loss topped 30%. That's three times the worst-case scenario for the Vanguard 500 fund. If we look at each portfolio's beta, a measure of its volatility compared with the S&P 500, we find that the Popular Portfolio was a much bumpier road, too. For reference, the S&P 500's beta is 1.0 and a higher beta implies more volatility.

Plain Jane Vs. the Popular Group A plain old index fund would have had competitive returns compared with the Popular Portfolio, with a lot less risk
Volatility
	Popular Portfolio	Vanguard 500 Index
Best Year	67.8%	52.0%
Worst Year	-31.8	-9.1
Three-Year Beta	1.34	1.0
Source: Morningstar. Returns through Feb. 28.

But even for tech fans, it didn't have to be that bad. For aggressive investors, most portfolio models prescribe a diversified portfolio that limits its sector-fund bets to 10% or less of your assets. This adds up to a 28.6% tech bet, which might be a happy medium for even those stricken with tech fever. If we compare the returns and risks of a portfolio with 90% of its money in the Vanguard 500 Index fund and 10% in the average tech fund, we find often-higher returns and less risk than the Popular Portfolio.

Over the past 10 years, the Popular Portfolio would've posted a 17.4% average annual gain, compared with 15.9% for the other. But the Popular Portfolio would've fallen short this year, over the past 12 months and over the past five years.

What a Little Tech Can Do Taking on a smaller dollop of tech funds in your index-weighted portfolio would do wonders against the Popular Portfolio
Volatility
	Popular Portfolio	Vanguard 500 Index
Best Year	67.8%	51.9%
Worst Year	-31.8	-14.1
Three-Year Beta	1.34	1.08
Source: Morningstar. Returns through Feb. 28.

Bringing bond and foreign-stock exposure would reduce risk even more. For instance, let's look at a portfolio with 80% of its money in the Vanguard 500 fund, 10% in the Vanguard Total Bond Market Index fund and 10% in the Tweedy, Browne Global Value fund. This fund would trail the Popular Portfolio over the past 10 years, but it would be down only 4.3% over the past year, compared with the Popular Portfolio's 31.8% fall.

This broader portfolio, which has a 21.3% tech weighting, still would've gained more than 45% in its best year, but its worst 12-month return was just 5%, according to Morningstar. Its beta or volatility along the way also was just 0.85%.

Stocks and Bonds Adding bonds and value offerings to your portfolio would have mitigated your losses this quarter and the past 12 months
Volatility
	Popular Portfolio	80%: (VFINX)Vanguard 500 Index10%: (VTSMX)Vanguard Total Bond Market Index10%: (TBGVX)Tweedy, Browne Global Value
Best Year	67.8%	45.6%
Worst Year	-31.8	-5
Three-Year Beta	1.34	0.85
Source: Morningstar. Returns through Feb. 28.

Well, there you have it. A few different ideas on how you might participate in up markets, without getting a healthy dose of account-statement shock.

>To order reprints of this article, click here: Reprints