Goldman Who? Small Bank Stocks to Own

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (TheStreet) -- German American Bancorp(GABC Quote) and Bank of Marin Bancorp(BMRC Quote) probably haven't been considered by investors who scooped up financial firms JPMorgan Chase(JPM Quote) and Goldman Sachs(GS Quote) on the cheap.

Although the largest banks, such as JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs, Wells Fargo(WFC Quote), Bank of America(BAC Quote) and Citigroup(C Quote), have posted stellar returns since financial stocks bottomed March 6, some small community banks have given them a run for their money as long-term investments.

TheStreet.com Ratings has "buy" recommendations for 32 of 439 bank holding companies. Most are unknown, including German American Bancorp and Bank of Marin Bancorp. Three other obscure picks are National Bankshares(NKSH Quote), Norwood Financial Corp.(NWFL Quote) and First of Long Island Corp.(FLIC Quote).

GRAPHIC: Interactive Bank Failure Map.

Our Five Bank-Stock Picks

An analysis of the recommended bank stocks shows that most had strong capital ratios and credit quality as of March 31, as well as low ratios of net charge-offs (loan losses) to average loans during the first quarter of 2009 and for all of last year.

We have taken a very conservative approach in narrowing the list to five bank holding companies with the highest 2008 returns on average assets that also met the following criteria:

1. Price-to-tangible-book-value ratio of less than 2. Tangible book value is defined as total equity capital minus goodwill and other intangibles, such as loan-servicing rights.

2. Net charge-off ratios of less than 1 for 2008 and the first quarter of 2009.

3. Nonperforming assets and nonperforming loan ratios of under 1%.

The following table includes total returns:

City State Symbol Price to Tangible Book Dividend Yield Closing Price - 3/6/09 Closing Price - 7/28/09 Total Return from 3/6/09 1 Year Total Return National Bankshares, Inc. Blacksburg Va. NKSH 1.73 3.09% $18.03 $25.39 43% 36% Norwood Financial Corp. Honesdale Pa. NWFL 1.47 3.30% $23.64 $32.52 40% 16% First of Long Island Corp. Glen Head N.Y. FLIC 1.76 2.75% $19.90 $26.31 34% 41% Bank of Marin Bancorp Novato Calif. BMRC 1.61 1.73% $17.80 $32.05 81% 15% German American Bancorp Jasper Ind. GABC 1.75 3.23% $10.51 $17.18 67% 52% Sources: Yield and Price-to-tangible-Book ratios - SNL Financial. Stock returns - Bloomberg.

The group of five haven't matched their larger rivals' incredible run-up from the March 6 bottom. But a glance at one-year returns is an eye opener, as all have had strong returns when many bank stocks were clobbered.